The Banking and Strategy Initiative

Chillin' out till it needs to be funded

ICICI Bank and the Bank of Rajasthan | Advantage 'zyaada'

Or, How the economic valuation at market prices has thrown the markets in disarray

It’s very satisfying, though a little strangely, to note the market reaction to Bank of Rajasthan’s final pricing for purchase by ICICI Bank. First let me get some mint writers and other acknowledgements out of the way. You will soon note that Chanda Kochchar would be asked and will reply in much the same manner on Television soon when she makes her whistlestop tour of the CNBC, NDTV and the rest of the dog and pony show.

Frankly, despite a very casual approach to accounting rules and a general laxity in willingness to enforce the law was , much to sadden my other banking colleagues, not the bete noire of the Bank of Rajasthan way of doing business. It was just another thing they did for the ethos and wealth saving strategies they lived by and there are a lot of these reasons why these old pvt sector banks have never been admitted to the ‘main street’ in Indian Finance. I would stop short at romanticising them however and just stop at the fact that their 500 branches bring a high amount of business to ICICI Bank’s book of INR 3.6 Trillion. BoR’s assets of INR 17k crores or $4.25 billion are rich in value with a low NPA of 1% and thus most Financial Analysts have given the valuation of 4.22 BOR shares for 1 ICICI share the green signal.

SEBI maintains that Tayals hold 55% in the bank and that would make them owners of nearly 1.87 crore ICICI Bank shares from new dilution by ICICI Bank, amounting to around 1.75% stake in the bank. ICICI Bank found it economic as always ( i can venture, they have it penned down in the guidelines) to invest in this deal on a 100% stock swap basis.

The rest is rather tiring and much will unfurl on its own in the next few days as the Tayals vie for media attention with Greece in the Indian context. Behold however, that the market, and much rightly, tries to bring down the ICICI Bank valuation to the paper terms of around $11 per share that is the value imputed from the ratio and thus 50% lower than the prices on BSE, NSE and the NYSE.

3 comments on “ICICI Bank and the Bank of Rajasthan | Advantage 'zyaada'

  1. Advantage zyaada
    May 19, 2010

    the valuation ratio is 4.72:1(25for118)
    at 100 Rs BoR share, ICICI Bk = 472 after 20% rise in BoR value,
    by merger valuation BOR share now worth 850/4.72 = 180


  2. zyakaira
    May 19, 2010

    read the mint analysis as well, very well done by Anita Bhoir and Anup for a first off the blocks story..

    “Transaction valued at $750mn and per branch acquisition cost at INR 7 crores”
    INR 7 Crores = $1.75 million


    May 27, 2010

    Dear Visitor,
    Thanks for visiting this nice and useful blog. As many events are about to happen soon. So we just want to share few things with all visitors as it might be helpful for everyone.

    NSE and BSE are trading in range and we are expecting breakout in the market after budget. One should buy quality stocks at every decline and should exit long positions at every rise.


    We will be discussing the various benefits of speed trading and its various coefficients using which one can make the most out of their investments in the Indian stock market including both Nifty and Sensex (NSE and BSE)


Comments are closed.


This entry was posted on May 19, 2010 by in Banking, Financial Markets, India and tagged , , , , .


%d bloggers like this: